Oil Change vs. Oil Filter Change: What’s the Difference?

When I first started doing my own car maintenance, I was convinced that changing the oil and changing the oil filter were the same thing. Spoiler alert: they’re not. And while both are essential for keeping your engine healthy, they play different roles in keeping your car running smoothly. So, if you’ve ever been unsure about what each involves (or how often to do them), you’re not alone—and this guide is here to clear things up.  

Oil Change vs. Oil Filter Change: What’s the Difference?  

The Basics of an Oil Change  

An oil change is exactly what it sounds like: you’re replacing the old, dirty oil in your engine with fresh, clean oil. Engine oil is the lifeblood of your car, lubricating all those moving parts to reduce friction, prevent overheating, and extend the life of your engine.  

Why It’s Important:  

Over time, oil breaks down and collects dirt, debris, and other gunk. This makes it less effective at protecting your engine. Fresh oil ensures that your engine stays properly lubricated and runs efficiently.  

What’s Involved in an Oil Change:  

•  Draining the old oil from the oil pan.  
•  Replacing it with the correct type and amount of new oil.  
•  Checking the oil level and ensuring there are no leaks.  

The Role of the Oil Filter  

Think of the oil filter as your engine’s first line of defense against contaminants. As oil circulates through your engine, it picks up dirt, metal shavings, and other particles. The oil filter traps these impurities, preventing them from circulating back into the engine and causing damage.  

Why It’s Important:  

A clogged or dirty oil filter can restrict oil flow, leading to poor lubrication and increased wear on engine parts. In extreme cases, it could even lead to engine failure.  

What’s Involved in an Oil Filter Change:  

•  Removing the old filter.  
•  Installing a new filter.  
•  Ensuring the new filter is seated properly and doesn’t leak.  

So, What’s the Difference?  

The main difference between an oil change and an oil filter change is what’s being replaced. An oil change focuses on swapping out the old oil, while an oil filter change replaces the filter that keeps the oil clean.  

However, here’s the kicker: you usually do both at the same time.  

Why You Should Replace the Oil Filter During an Oil Change  

While you technically could just replace the oil without changing the filter, it’s not a great idea. A dirty filter will contaminate your fresh oil almost immediately, negating the benefits of the oil change. It’s like putting clean water into a dirty glass—it defeats the purpose.  

When to Replace the Oil Filter:  

Most mechanics and manufacturers recommend replacing the oil filter every time you change your oil.  

If you’re stretching the time between oil changes (which you shouldn’t do, by the way), you might need to replace the filter more frequently.  

How Often Should You Change Your Oil and Filter?  

Ah, the ageold question. The answer depends on your car, your driving habits, and the type of oil you’re using.  

•  Conventional Oil: Needs to be changed every 3,000–5,000 miles.  
•  Synthetic Oil: Lasts longer, typically 7,500–10,000 miles.  

Check your owner’s manual for specific recommendations. The oil filter is usually replaced at the same intervals, though some filters are designed to last longer.  

Common Mistakes People Make  

1. Skipping the Oil Filter Change:  

Trust me, I’ve been tempted to skip it to save a few bucks. But a dirty filter can wreak havoc on your engine, making it a costly mistake in the long run.  

2. Using the Wrong Oil or Filter:  

Not all oils and filters are created equal. Your car’s manual will specify the right type of oil (e.g., 5W30 synthetic) and compatible filters.  

3. OverTightening the Oil Filter:  

I learned this one the hard way. Overtightening can damage the filter seal and make it a nightmare to remove later. Tighten it snugly but not excessively.  

4. Waiting Too Long Between Changes:  

Yes, synthetic oil lasts longer, but pushing it past its limits is a gamble. It’s better to stick to a regular schedule.  

Final Thoughts: Do You Need Both?  

Short answer: Yes.  

While an oil change and oil filter change are technically separate tasks, they go hand in hand. Skipping one or the other is like brushing your teeth without flossing—it’s better than nothing, but it’s not ideal.  

Keeping up with both ensures your engine stays in top shape, reduces the risk of expensive repairs, and keeps your car running smoothly for years to come. So, next time you see that little oil light on your dashboard, remember: fresh oil and a clean filter are the dynamic duo your engine needs.  

Share this post